Better Work Vietnam was established in 2009 to improve working conditions and competitiveness in the country’s garment sector. One of the principal strategies used to achieve these goals is to develop enterprise-level bipartite worker-management committees – Performance Improvement Consultative Committees (PICCs) – to encourage dialogue and joint problem solving. This research brief summarizes the findings from an independent research project that explored the causes and outcomes of recent strike activity in Vietnam, and asked whether improved communication through the PICC dialogue mechanism reduces the incidence of such events.
The research finds that worker-management committees such as PICCs may contribute to lower strike rates if they maintain a certain level of quality as a dialogue mechanism. They have the most potential to prevent strikes when combined with other well-functioning employment relations institutions. In order for PICCs (and similar bipartite mechanisms) to fulfil this potential, the researcher identifies four interrelated factors that must be present. Workers participating in the committee must be: : 1) freely elected, 2) able to carry out their representative function, 3) protected from retaliation, and 4) empowered to advocate for their positions. The study finds considerable variation in these factors – and overall quality – among PICCs studied, and also notes that all have room for improvement.
The study also concludes that well-functioning PICCs alone are not sufficient to reduce strike rates, arguing that only with independent and fully representative unions, which elect their leaders and engage in proper collective bargaining processes, can the root causes of industrial unrest be fully and sustainably addressed.
Read more
The Effectiveness of Better Work Training
Countries, Data and Evidence, Global, Global Resources, Research Briefs, Resources, Theme, Training, Type of publication
Better Work Jordan: Worker, Supervisor and Manager Survey Results – 2021
Countries, COVID19, Data and Evidence, Jordan, Productivity and Business Performance, Research Briefs, Resources for Jordan
Working Conditions, Productivity and Profitability Evidence from Better Work Vietnam
Business-related, Countries, Data and Evidence, Productivity and Business Performance, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Vietnam, Theme, Type of publication, Vietnam
Progress and Potential: Better Work Haiti
Countries, Data and Evidence, Haiti, Impact Assessment, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Haiti, Theme, Type of publication
Oversight and Openness: Reflections on brand-supplier interaction from the Better Work Academy
Countries, Featured Publication, Global Resources, Industrial Relations, Productivity and Business Performance, Research Briefs, Resources, Theme, Type of publication
Gender and Care Responsibilities: Examining the differences for garment workers in Better Factories Cambodia
Cambodia, Countries, Gender and Inclusion, Research Briefs, Resources for Cambodia
A focus on firm performance
Business-related, Countries, Data and Evidence, Featured, Global, Global Resources, Impact Assessment, Research Briefs, Resources, Theme, Type of publication
Better Work Vietnam: Impact Brief
Countries, Data and Evidence, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Vietnam, Theme, Type of publication, Vietnam
Progress and Potential: Jordan Country Brief
Countries, Data and Evidence, Impact Assessment, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Theme, Type of publication
Advancing Jordan’s satellite garment factories
Countries, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Theme, Type of publication
Better Factories Cambodia Transparency Database Report, 9th Cycle
Cambodia, Countries, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Cambodia, Type of publication
Better Work Haiti COVID-19 Economic Impact Survey
Countries, COVID19, Haiti, Occupational Safety and Health, Research Briefs, Resources for Haiti
Better Factories Cambodia Transparency Database Report, 10th Cycle
Cambodia, Countries, Data and Evidence, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Cambodia, Type of publication
Better Work Haiti COVID-19 Business Impact Survey
Countries, COVID19, Data and Evidence, Haiti, Occupational Safety and Health, Productivity and Business Performance, Research Briefs, Resources for Haiti, Type of publication
Impact Research: Jordan Baseline Report – Worker Perspectives from the Factory and Beyond
Countries, Data and Evidence, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Theme, Type of publication
Progress and Potential: Vietnam Country Brief
Countries, Data and Evidence, Impact Assessment, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Vietnam, Type of publication, Vietnam
The Business Benefits of Better Factories Cambodia
Cambodia, Countries, Data and Evidence, Productivity and Business Performance, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Cambodia, Theme, Type of publication
The Apparel Industry: Jordan’s Comparative Advantage in International Trade
Countries, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Type of publication
Sexual harassment at work: Insights from the global garment industry
Countries, Gender and Inclusion, Global, Global Resources, Research Briefs, Resources, Type of publication
The Apparel Industry and the Jordanian Economy: Calculating the Domestic Share of Sector Value Added
Countries, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Type of publication
Progress and Potential: Indonesia Country Brief
Countries, Data and Evidence, Impact Assessment, Indonesia, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Indonesia, Theme, Type of publication
The Impact of Better Work on Firm Performance
Indonesia, Jordan, Research Briefs, Vietnam
Better Factories Cambodia Transparency Database Report, 7th Cycle
Cambodia, Countries, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Cambodia, Type of publication
Fire and building safety in the ready-made garment sector of Bangladesh
Bangladesh, Case Study, Countries, Occupational Safety and Health, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Bangladesh, Theme, Type of publication
The Better Work Academy: approach and impact in Gap Inc. factories.
Bangladesh, Cambodia, Countries, Data and Evidence, Indonesia, Research Briefs, Resources for Bangladesh, Resources for Cambodia, Resources for Indonesia, Resources for Vietnam, Vietnam
Better Work and State Regulation in Indonesia – Towards Reinforcement
Countries, Indonesia, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Indonesia, Type of publication
Better Work Jordan: Impact Brief
Countries, Data and Evidence, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Type of publication
Baseline Report: Worker Perspectives from the Factory and Beyond
Countries, Data and Evidence, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Theme, Type of publication
The supply chain ripple effect: How COVID-19 is affecting garment workers and factories in Asia and the Pacific
COVID19, Global, Global Resources, Occupational Safety and Health, Productivity and Business Performance, Research Briefs
Jordanian Workers for the Garment Industry – Challenges and Prospects
Countries, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Type of publication
Better Factories Cambodia Transparency Database Report, 11th Cycle
Cambodia, Countries, Data and Evidence, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Cambodia, Theme, Type of publication
Better Work Jordan Impact Assessment (Manager Report)
Countries, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Type of publication
Better Work Jordan: Worker Well-being in Jordan’s Garment Sector
Countries, Jordan, Occupational Safety and Health, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan
COVID-19: Garment worker perspectives in Jordan
Countries, COVID19, Jordan, Occupational Safety and Health, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Type of publication
Better Work Jordan: Evaluation of Digital Training Modalities for the Jordanian Garment Sector
Case Study, Jordan, Reports, Research Briefs, Resources for Jordan
Worker and Management Perceptions of the Impact of Better Work Lesotho
Industrial Relations, Lesotho, Research Briefs
Case Study: Transparency in Cambodia’s Garment Sector
Cambodia, Case Study, Countries, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Cambodia, Type of publication
Better Work Jordan – Factory Survey 2015
Case Study, Countries, Impact Evaluation, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Type of publication
Better Work Jordan Worker Voice Survey Results
Countries, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources for Jordan, Social Dialogue, Type of publication
A focus on gender
Countries, Data and Evidence, Featured, Gender and Inclusion, Global, Global Resources, Impact Assessment, Research Briefs, Resources, Theme
A focus on the Sustainable Development Goals
Case Study, Countries, Global, Global Resources, Research Briefs, Resources, Type of publication
The Case Against Verbal Abuses in Garment Factories
Research Briefs
Addressing Sexual Harassment in Jordan’s garment industry
Case Study, Countries, Gender and Inclusion, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Training, Type of publication
Better Work Jordan: Worker and Manager Survey Results November 2020
Countries, COVID19, Jordan, Occupational Safety and Health, Research Briefs, Resources for Jordan, Social Dialogue
Garment Factory Characteristics and Workplace Sexual Harassment
Countries, Gender and Inclusion, Global, Global Resources, Research Briefs, Resources
Strikes and bipartite committees in Vietnam: Evidence from Better Work
Countries, Data and Evidence, Industrial Relations, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Vietnam, Social Dialogue, Theme, Type of publication, Vietnam
A focus on occupational safety and health
Business-related, Countries, Featured, Global, Global Resources, Impact Assessment, Occupational Safety and Health, Research Briefs, Resources, Theme, Type of publication
Harnessing Compliance to Improve Well-being and Productivity: The Impact of Better Factories Cambodia
Cambodia, Countries, Occupational Safety and Health, Productivity and Business Performance, Research Briefs, Resources for Cambodia, Social Dialogue, Wages
Improving Business Outcomes by Understanding What Matters to Workers
Countries, Global, Global Resources, Research Briefs, Resources, Type of publication
A focus on sourcing practices from a factory perspective
Countries, Data and Evidence, Featured, Global, Global Resources, Impact Assessment, Research Briefs, Resources, Type of publication
Better Work Haiti: Impact Brief
Countries, Data and Evidence, Haiti, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Haiti, Theme, Type of publication
Annual Factory Survey Results, 2014
Case Study, Countries, Impact Evaluation, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Jordan, Type of publication
Gender Equality – Findings from Vietnam
Countries, Gender and Inclusion, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Vietnam, Theme, Type of publication, Vietnam
Women, Work & Development
Countries, Gender and Inclusion, Global, Global Resources, Research Briefs, Resources, Theme, Type of publication
Progress and Potential: Nicaragua Country Brief
Countries, Data and Evidence, Impact Assessment, Nicaragua, Research Briefs, Resources, Resources for Nicaragua, Type of publication
Better Work Jordan: Worker and Manager Survey Results
Countries, COVID19, Jordan, Research Briefs, Resources for Jordan, Social Dialogue, Theme