Global consumers, international brands, and governments in producing and outsourcing countries aim to improve working conditions in global value chains, but uncertainty exists about what is the best approach. This research uses firm-level data from the International Labour Organization–International Finance Corporation Better Work Vietnam program to assess the relationship between transparency on working conditions and firm compliance in the apparel sector in Vietnam between 2010 and 2018. It exploits a change in the policies of Better Work Vietnam when, in 2015, the program announced the launch of a new public disclosure program that would see factories’ names made publicly available along with their compliance (or lack thereof) with certain “critical issues.” The paper first examines which firm characteristics correlate with reductions in noncompliance rates over time, and then examines the impact of the public disclosure policy on compliance rates and firm dropout using different empirical techniques. It finds that while continued participation in the Better Work Vietnam program has the strongest effect on changes in firm compliance with labor standards over time, public disclosure is also associated with increased compliance, with stronger effects in some compliance points, including occupational health and safety, work time, and child labor. There is some evidence of increased dropout, but no evidence of firms only making progress on the critical issues is found. The research findings suggest that public disclosure within global value chains matters for firm behavior.
Read more
Discussion Paper 13: Analysing Better Work Data from a Gender Perspective
Discussion Papers, Gender and Inclusion, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 12: Is There an Efficiency Case For International Labour Standards?
Cambodia, Discussion Papers
Discussion paper 16: Sexual Harassment in the Workplace: How does it Affect firm Performance and Profits
Discussion Papers, Gender and Inclusion, Haiti, Indonesia, Jordan, Nicaragua, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 25: Examining Barriers to Workforce Inclusion of Syrian Refugees in Jordan
Discussion Papers, Featured, Jordan
DP 44: Piece Rate, Productivity and Occupational Health in the Global Economy
Cambodia, Discussion Papers
Discussion Paper 1: Labour Law Compliance and Human Resource Management Innovation
Cambodia, Discussion Papers
Discussion Paper 14: Sexual Harassment in Garment Factories: Firm Structure, Organizational Culture and Incentive Systems
Discussion Papers, Gender and Inclusion, Haiti, Indonesia, Jordan
Discussion Paper 24: Wildcat strikes and Better Work bipartite committees in Vietnam
Discussion Papers, Featured, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 15: The Business Case Against Verbal Abuse
Discussion Papers, Indonesia, Jordan, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 2: Excessive Overtime, Workers and Productivity
Cambodia, Discussion Papers, Haiti, Indonesia, Jordan, Lesotho, Nicaragua, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 33 – Supporting Mental Well-being of Migrant Garment Workers in Jordan
Discussion Papers, Jordan
Discussion Paper 27: The impact of Better Work – Firm performance in Vietnam, Indonesia and Jordan
Discussion Papers, Indonesia, Jordan, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 19: Survival of the Fittest – And Most Compliant
Cambodia, Discussion Papers
Discussion Paper 36: Automation, employment and reshoring in the apparel industry
Bangladesh, Cambodia, Discussion Papers, Egypt, Ethiopia, Global Resources, Haiti, Indonesia, Jordan, Nicaragua, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 18: Occupational Safety and Health Conditions in the Apparel Factories
Discussion Papers, Jordan, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 35: Better Work Beyond the Workplace
Bangladesh, Cambodia, Discussion Papers, Gender and Inclusion, Lesotho, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 48: Labor Compliance Programs in Developing Countries and Trade Flows
Countries, Data and Evidence, Discussion Papers, Featured Publication, Global, Global Resources, Productivity and Business Performance, Theme, Type of publication
Discussion Paper 46 : Workers’ Voice within and beyond Participation Committees
Bangladesh, Countries, Discussion Papers, Featured Publication, Global Resources, Industrial Relations, Theme, Type of publication
Discussion Paper 29: Lights On: Transparency and Compliance – Evidence from Cambodia
Cambodia, Discussion Papers
Discussion Paper 31: Firm Compliance and Public Disclosure in Vietnam
Discussion Papers, Featured, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 10: Do Factory Managers Know what Workers Want?
Discussion Papers, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 41: Worker Voice and Labor Standards – Study of Participation Committees in Supply Chains
Discussion Papers, Indonesia, Jordan, Vietnam
DP 45: Sourcing Practices in the Garment Industry, The Root Cause for Poor Working Conditions
Cambodia, Discussion Papers
Discussion Paper 40: Impacts on the Shop Floor – An Evaluation of the Better Work – Gap Inc. program on Workplace Cooperation
Bangladesh, Cambodia, Discussion Papers, Indonesia, Resources for Bangladesh, Resources for Cambodia, Resources for Indonesia, Resources for Vietnam, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 34: The Jordanian Garment Industry and Better Work
Discussion Papers, Jordan
Discussion Paper 3: Apparel Wages Before and After Better Factories Cambodia
Cambodia, Discussion Papers
Discussion Paper 22: Training for supervisors: discussion paper on the impacts
Cambodia, Discussion Papers, Haiti, Indonesia, Jordan, Lesotho, Nicaragua, Training, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 11: The Role of Variegated Capitalism in Vietnam’s Garment Sector
Discussion Papers, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 7: Lesotho Clothing Workers’ Perceptions of What Makes Better Work
Discussion Papers, Lesotho
Discussion Paper 47: Learning from Crisis
COVID19, Discussion Papers, Featured, Featured Publication, Global Resources, Occupational Safety and Health
Discussion Paper 30: An Impact Evaluation of Better Work from a Gender Perspective
Discussion Papers, Haiti, Indonesia, Jordan, Nicaragua, Vietnam
Discussion paper 17: Are Sweatshops Profit-Maximizing?
Discussion Papers, Vietnam
Discussion paper 21: The Interaction of Labour Inspection and Private Compliance Initiatives
Case Study, Discussion Papers, Indonesia
Discussion Paper 37: Labour Standards Compliance in the Global Garment Supply Chain
Bangladesh, Cambodia, Countries, Discussion Papers, Haiti, Indonesia, Jordan, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 39: Is Social Compliance Win-Win for Workers and Firms? Evidence from Better Factories Cambodia
Cambodia, Discussion Papers, Resources for Cambodia
Discussion Paper 38: Sexual Harassment – Causes and Remediation
Cambodia, Discussion Papers, Gender and Inclusion, Resources for Cambodia
Discussion Paper 23: Labour Compliance and Factory Performance
Business-related, Cambodia, Discussion Papers
Discussion Paper 28: Piece rate pay and working conditions in the export garment sector
Discussion Papers, Haiti, Indonesia, Jordan, Nicaragua, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 26: Does Piece Rate Pay Impact Perceived Occupational Hazards in Garment Factories?
Discussion Papers, Vietnam
Discussion Paper 9: Global Production Networks and Variegated Capitalism
Cambodia, Discussion Papers
Discussion Paper 5: Does Better Labour Standard Compliance Pay?
Cambodia, Discussion Papers
- Category: Discussion Paper
- Publication: September 2019
- Series No: 31
- Author: Claire H. Hollweg